
GUIDE
Exchange Failure: Are You an Owner or a Creditor?
Crypto Bank Editorial Team · November 18, 2026
The most consequential fact about a crypto balance on a platform is invisible on the screen. Two clients can see the same number and stand in completely different legal positions: one owns identifiable assets that a court should return; the other is owed a sum and waits in line with every other unsecured creditor. Which one you are was fixed by documents you accepted before anything went wrong.
Two positions behind one balance
An owner of assets held separately for them can generally ask for those assets back when the custodian fails. The assets are outside the bankruptcy estate, so other creditors have no claim on them.
A creditor has handed over title and holds a claim. In an insolvency, creditors are paid in order of rank: secured creditors first, then whatever preferential classes the local law creates, then general unsecured creditors, which is where platform customers usually land if they are not owners. Recovery is a percentage, it takes years, and claims are often valued in money at the date proceedings opened, so a later rise in the asset’s price does not reach the claimant.
What decides which one you are
The words in the terms
Look for the custody clause, typically under a heading about digital assets or title. Phrases such as “you own”, “held on trust” or “for the benefit of” point toward ownership. Language allowing the platform to use, lend, pledge or rehypothecate client assets points the other way, because rehypothecation turns your asset into someone else’s collateral. Kraken’s EEA terms are an example of the first kind: clients own the crypto in their account, Kraken holds it “upon trust”, and it will not be lent or hypothecated unless the client instructs it (profile).
Whether segregation is real
Segregation means client assets are kept apart from the firm’s own and are not used to run the business. It is undermined in two common ways. Assets can be separate on paper but pooled in practice, so that no individual holding can be identified. And terms can permit lending, so that what was segregated is no longer there. Our guide to segregated versus omnibus accounts covers the spectrum.
Which entity you contracted with
Large platforms are groups of companies. The entity named in your terms may not be the one that holds the assets, and either may be incorporated far from where you live. That entity determines the court, the insolvency regime and the creditor hierarchy. Customers of two entities under one brand can fare very differently in a single collapse.
The custodian’s own legal theory
Regulated custodians usually publish their view, and the honest ones qualify it. Fidelity’s bitcoin fund describes an arrangement in which bitcoin is treated as a financial asset under Article 8 of the New York Uniform Commercial Code, held in an omnibus account separate from the custodian’s proprietary assets, and then notes that bankruptcy courts “have not yet fully addressed” custodial digital assets (profile). Coinbase warns its shareholders that custodially held crypto “may be considered to be the property of a bankruptcy estate” (profile). Anchorage argues the opposite for its national trust bank: client assets held in trust do not become part of the estate (profile). The disagreement is itself useful information.
What happened when it was tested
FTX halted withdrawals in November 2022 and its group entered bankruptcy proceedings; Fidelity’s fund filing records the halt and the filing. From that point, customers’ position turned on how their claims were classified in the proceedings. Our guide on what precedent shows walks through the cases in more depth. The general lesson is consistent: the outcome followed the paperwork and the corporate structure, not the marketing.
Where insurance fits, and where it does not
Platform insurance, where it exists, is usually crime or specie cover aimed at theft from the custodian’s storage. It does not make a client whole when a platform simply owes more than it holds. BitGo’s filing, unusually explicit, describes up to $250 million of cover for assets in qualified custody with “a long list of terms and conditions, constraints and exclusions” (profile). Kraken states plainly that accounts “are not covered by insurance against losses.” Deposit insurance does not extend to crypto: Anchorage and Fidelity both say custodied digital assets are not FDIC-insured.
The Custody Question, applied
- Who holds the keys: the platform or its sub-custodian. Find the entity, not the brand.
- Who insures it: read the policy summary. A theft policy is not insolvency protection.
- What happens on default: owner or creditor, decided by the custody clause, the segregation in practice and the governing law.
Four checks before depositing
- Name the legal entity in the terms and where it is incorporated.
- Find the custody clause: ownership and trust language, or permission to use your assets?
- Identify the entity’s licence or registration and what it actually requires; an anti-money-laundering registration is not a custody authorisation.
- Read what any advertised insurance covers, and what it excludes.
None of this makes platforms unusable. It makes the exposure explicit, which is the point: idle balances left for months are a decision, and better made while withdrawals still work.
Sources
- Kraken EEA Terms of Service and disclosures, checked 2026-11-18
- Fidelity Wise Origin Bitcoin Fund, Form 10-K for 2025, checked 2026-11-18
- Coinbase Global, Inc., Form 10-K for 2025, checked 2026-11-18
- BitGo Holdings, Inc., Form 10-K for 2025, checked 2026-11-18
- Anchorage Digital primer on asset protection, checked 2026-11-18
Editorial explainer, not financial or legal advice. Crypto Bank is not a bank and does not hold client assets.