cryptobank
Crypto Bank is an independent editorial publication. It is not a bank, is not a deposit-taking or custodial institution, holds no banking, trust, money-transmitter or e-money licence, and offers no FDIC or FSCS protection. Nothing here is financial, legal or investment advice.
BTC $63,224-0.77% ETH $1,773-0.88% USDT $1.00+0.10% USDC $1.00+0.01% SOL $73.99+2.41% XRP $0.98+2.53% BNB $584-0.40% ADA $0.15+0.59%
Client Assets in Insolvency: What Real Precedent Shows

GUIDE

Client Assets in Insolvency: What Real Precedent Shows

Crypto Bank Editorial Team · November 17, 2026

What happens to a client’s crypto when the company holding it fails is not a hypothetical anymore. Several real insolvencies have gone through courts far enough to produce actual rulings, and the rulings have not all gone the same way — because the outcome has turned out to depend less on the word “custody” and more on the specific contract language and legal structure each company used. This guide walks through documented cases rather than generic predictions, because the generic version of this question is less useful than the specific answers courts have actually given.

Why contract language, not intuition, decides the outcome

The starting legal question in almost every one of these cases is the same: when the client’s crypto arrived at the company, did legal title to it transfer to the company (making it the company’s own property, and the client simply an unsecured creditor with a claim for its value), or did the company merely hold the asset on the client’s behalf (as a bailee or trustee, meaning the asset stays legally the client’s and generally sits outside the company’s bankruptcy estate)? That question is answered by the specific terms of service the client agreed to, and by how a court reads them — not by whether the company called itself a “custodian” in its marketing.

Celsius: terms of use decided it, and the court said so plainly

In January 2023, the US bankruptcy court overseeing the Celsius Network case ruled that crypto assets deposited into Celsius’s “Earn” program became Celsius’s own property at the moment of deposit, based squarely on the wording of Celsius’s Terms of Use. The court rejected arguments that the terms were ambiguous or merely a clickwrap agreement without binding effect, and found the contract language clear enough to control the outcome. The practical result: Earn account holders were treated as unsecured creditors of the Celsius estate, not as owners of specific, recoverable coins.

Two details matter beyond the headline. First, the ruling was expressly limited to the Earn program — it did not resolve the separate question of how assets in Celsius’s custody-labeled program should be treated, which shows that even within one company, different product lines with different terms can produce different legal outcomes. Second, the court reserved individual defenses (including claims that the contract was procured by fraud, or violated securities law) for later proceedings, meaning the headline ruling on contract interpretation was not the final word on every claim.

Cryptopia: the opposite result, on different facts

Cryptopia, a New Zealand exchange, was hacked and went into liquidation in 2019. In April 2020, the New Zealand High Court ruled, in Ruscoe v Cryptopia Ltd (in liquidation), that the cryptocurrencies held by the exchange were “property” under New Zealand law and at common law, and that Cryptopia held each type of cryptocurrency on separate express trusts for the account holders who held that currency — meaning those assets were never part of Cryptopia’s own estate available to its general creditors. That is close to the opposite outcome from Celsius’s Earn accounts, reached under different law, on a different company’s facts and contract terms.

The Cryptopia case did not end with that 2020 ruling. The liquidation has continued for years afterward, with later High Court applications (including a 2024 decision on a joinder application) dealing with the practical question of how to actually distribute the trust assets among account holders — a reminder that even a favorable “it’s held on trust” ruling is the start of a long distribution process, not an immediate return of assets.

Mt. Gox: a different legal path entirely

Mt. Gox, once the dominant bitcoin exchange, collapsed in 2014 under Japanese bankruptcy proceedings. In 2018, a Tokyo court approved moving the case from ordinary bankruptcy into a Japanese civil rehabilitation process, a different procedure that allowed creditors to pursue claims for the return of their original cryptocurrency holdings rather than being paid out based on the (much lower) fiat value of bitcoin at the time of the 2014 collapse. A rehabilitation plan was approved by the court in 2021, and actual distributions of bitcoin and bitcoin cash to creditors began in 2024 — roughly a decade after the original collapse. The case illustrates a different lesson from Celsius and Cryptopia: the choice of insolvency procedure itself (liquidation versus rehabilitation) can determine whether creditors are paid in the asset they lost or in its cash value at a point that may be far less favorable to them, and that even a successful outcome for creditors can take many years to actually pay out.

FTX: a different failure mode entirely

FTX’s 2022 collapse is a useful contrast precisely because it was not primarily a contract-interpretation dispute like Celsius or Cryptopia. FTX’s own founder was convicted on criminal fraud charges related to the misuse of customer funds, which were found to have been transferred to an affiliated trading firm rather than held as represented to customers. Where Celsius and Cryptopia turned on how a court should read ambiguous or clear contract terms describing an otherwise-functioning custody arrangement, FTX’s case turned on the assets not having been held the way the company told customers they were being held at all. The lesson for a reader evaluating any custodian is that terms-of-service analysis assumes the provider is telling the truth about what it does with client assets; it is not a substitute for independent verification of that claim, which is exactly the gap a proof of reserves partially, imperfectly, tries to close.

What to ask before assuming an outcome

  • Does the provider’s terms of service describe client assets as held in trust, as bailment, or does title pass to the provider? This single clause is what Celsius’s case turned on.
  • Is that description consistent across every product line the provider offers, or does a “custody” product carry different terms from an “earn” or “yield” product under the same brand?
  • Which jurisdiction’s insolvency law would apply, and does that jurisdiction recognize crypto-assets as property capable of being held on trust, the way the New Zealand court did for Cryptopia?
  • If the provider has published no information on any of this, what jurisdiction is it even organized in — the starting point for finding out which court would eventually decide the question?

The pattern across these cases

  • The label does not decide the outcome. Celsius, Cryptopia and Mt. Gox were all described using words like “custody,” “exchange” or “wallet” by their users, and still produced different legal results.
  • The specific contract, and the specific court, do. Terms of service wording, the jurisdiction’s property and trust law, and the particular insolvency procedure invoked all independently shape the outcome.
  • Segregation and trust language in the terms of service is the single most load-bearing detail. See our segregated vs. omnibus accounts guide for how this plays out operationally before a failure ever happens.
  • Timelines are long. Years, not months, between a collapse and an actual distribution to creditors has been the norm in every case above, regardless of how the legal question was ultimately resolved.

The third row of the Custody Question

This is exactly what the third row of our Custody Question panel — what happens on default — is asking about: not a general assurance, but a specific, sourced answer about how a named jurisdiction’s law and a provider’s own contract terms would treat client assets if the provider failed. Where that answer is not disclosed anywhere discoverable, we say so rather than guessing, because as the cases above show, guessing from the word “custody” alone has produced wrong answers before.

FAQ

Does “my coins are in cold storage” protect me in an insolvency?
Not by itself. Where the assets are stored (hot, warm, or cold) is a security and operational question; whether they are legally yours or part of the company’s estate is a separate, contract-and-trust-law question, and the two can point in different directions.
If a company calls itself a “custodian,” does that guarantee client assets are off-balance-sheet?
No. As Celsius showed, the specific program’s terms of service controlled the outcome, not the general label the company used for itself or for different products within the same company.
Are retail depositors ever treated better than other creditors?
It depends entirely on the jurisdiction’s insolvency law and the specific priority rules that apply, which vary and are not something this guide can generalize safely. This is a question for a qualified insolvency lawyer in the relevant jurisdiction, not a general guide.

Risk note

This guide describes the outcomes of specific, named, concluded court rulings as reported at the time of writing; it is not legal advice, and insolvency law varies by jurisdiction and continues to develop through new cases. If you are assessing a specific provider or a specific jurisdiction’s law, consult a qualified lawyer in that jurisdiction rather than relying on the general pattern described here.

Not a bank. Not a deposit-taking institution. No FDIC, FSCS or deposit-insurance cover. Editorial only.

Not financial advice. Not legal advice.